|Vaccination - The Pros and Cons|
Dr. Sarah Myhill
I have concerns about immunisations in general because I suspect they result in an overall gradual erosion of the immune system. This is compounded by excessive use of antibiotics, excessive use of hygiene (mothers who bring up their children in squeaky clean environments put them at high risk of allergy and asthma), the depletion of micronutrients in our diets as a result of modern food choices and agriculture techniques and the exposure to toxins such as pesticides and heavy metals.
There are some vaccinations which I believe are essential such as polio, tetanus, diphtheria and possibly whooping cough. They have also been around for a long time and we think we know the problems. I think that the evidence for other vaccinations is less certain and each case needs dealing with individually. Hepatitis B is a difficult one and should probably be given to 'at risk' groups. I am particularly concerned about vaccinations which are given altogether such as for example MMR. Nowhere in nature is one likely to meet up with several viruses in one go and I think this may explain some of the problems which follow vaccination. As a general principle try to be as healthy as possible on vaccination day!
Vaccination and CFS. Vaccinations are a two edged sword because whilst they have the potential to prevent illness, they can certainly cause flares of CFS. Indeed I have several patients with CFS dated from vaccinations such as flu or hepatitis B. However usually this has been on the background of overwhelming stress
Influenza vaccination: should you have one? One of the commonest triggers of a flare of CFS is flu. One can usually expect a mini epidemic most winters and a major epidemic one in every four winters. If you are the sort of person who regularly gets flu every winter then I would recommend you have a flu vaccine. If you are the sort of person who could become very ill as a result of flu (such as heart failure, chronic chest etc) you should consider flu vaccination. If you are the sort of person who never gets flu, then I would not care to risk flu vaccination. Between the two there is a grey area and it is for each individual person to decide for themselves what is the best thing to do.
MMR vaccination: I think the evidence that the MMR vaccine causing autism is strong and I would not like to use this mixed vaccine in any child. In any case it is a complete waste of time giving rubella to boys and mumps to girls. Girls do not need rubella vaccination until they are sexually mature and by this time they will have had a good chance to have the infection and be naturally immune. Measles is a nasty illness and there probably is a case for vaccination young, but not in combination with the other viruses.
The trouble in UK is that the Government has banned the use of the individual vaccines measles and mumps. However with a doctors letter it is now possible to get these vaccinations individually. They can be ordered through IDIS 0208 410 0700.
Gulf War Syndrome. GWS is a classic example of a CFS with several causes. One probably cause was the many vaccinations that the soldiers received in one day. Some said they had 14 injections at one session. It is perfectly possible that this could have caused some sort of immune disruption resulting in CFS.
Polio vaccination: an example of what could go wrong. The epidemic of CFS we are seeing at the moment may be partly caused by polio vaccination. Before polio vaccination, everybody got the polio virus at some stage in their lives and a few developed paralysis as a result. As a result of the immune system fighting the real polio virus an immunity to all enteroviruses was stimulated. These enteroviruses included Epstein Barr virus (glandular fever), ECHO, coxsackie B etc. Polio vaccination gave immunity against polio, but not these other enteroviruses. Enteroviruses are a major cause of post viral syndrome. Indeed it has been estimated that over 20% of people who get glandular fever never recover their full energy levels.
So we have swapped one problem for another, less polio paralysis, but more post viral syndrome.
My concerns about vaccinations. My philosophy is always 'mimic Nature'. A vaccination will never produce the same strength of immunity as getting the real infection. My worries are: The insidious erosion of the immune system. Giving vaccinations may block very useful cross immunity to other viruses. For example there are some viruses which cause cancer. I do not wish to inadvertently block immunity to one of those! We are constantly meeting new viruses and our bodies have to learn to cope with them.. We have no idea of what long term problems we are storing up.
Amazon.com Recommended Books:
|Last Updated on Monday, 24 January 2011 22:32|